Saskatoon group caught with kilos of meth is back on trial after judge overturns acquittal
A man and woman in Saskatoon who had two kilograms of methamphetamine seized from a home are going back to trial after having their acquittals overturned.
The Saskatoon Police Service received information that Thomas James Arendt and Kayleigha Shaneih Anneleise Bear may be involved in drug trafficking in 2022. They began surveillance of Arendt’s home, observed several short meetings with him and visitors, and applied for a search warrant based on that information.
When their application was rejected, the officer applying for the warrant — the affiant — revised the application based on the shortcomings described by the judge, and resubmitted. After getting the warrant, police searched the home and found about two kilograms of methamphetamine, cash and paraphernalia.
Arendt and Bear were later acquitted of the charges when a judge reviewed the warrant application and found Saskatoon police had fabricated details about the suspects that didn’t match the surveillance logs they were drawn from.
As a result, the seized drugs weren’t admissible as evidence, and the two were acquitted of the charges. The Crown lawyers appealed that judgment in April.
Now, three justices on Saskatchewan’s highest court have sided with the Crown.
While they agreed there were clear issues with the warrant, Justice Brian Barrington-Foote writes the judge overstepped his limited role in reviewing the warrant application. More than just removing inaccuracies, the reviewing judge went so far as determining the affiant was not an accurate witness.
By comparing the surveillance logs to what was written in the warrant application, reviewing judge Quentin Agnew found the police were overstating their evidence by including elements that were “entirely fictional,” including a description of one person emerging from Arendt’s house, hunched over and manipulating what police believed to be drugs.
“This ‘observation’ has no basis in the evidence, and accordingly, neither does the commentary,” Agnew wrote.
In their application, police alluded to previous drug trafficking and weapons charges against Arendt, even though he was acquitted or received a stay of proceedings on those counts — no convictions.
Agnew also took issue with the way police phrased their observations to imply guilt, without reference to further evidence.
“The weakness of the affiant’s evidence, in referring to events ‘believed to be’ or ‘consistent with’ drug transactions, and the weakness of assertions based on the affiant’s ‘experience as a police officer and drug investigator’ without further explanation” cast the entire application into doubt, Agnew wrote.
However, the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal says it wasn’t Agnew’s role to determine the overall credibility of the investigators, simply to remove portions of the warrant application that were inaccurate.
“He mistakenly held that it fell to him as the reviewing judge to determine whether the affiant and the evidence remaining after the excisions were reliable,” Barrington-Foote said.
“By doing so, he substituted his view for that of the issuing judge,” he said.
“I am persuaded that, absent the legal error, he may well have reached a different bottom-line conclusion.”
Since Arendt and Bear were acquitted after Agnew deemed the seized drugs inadmissible as evidence, the decision of the appeal court means their acquittals have been overturned and they’re heading back to trial.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
W5 INVESTIGATES Jungle crackdown: Shutting down a treacherous narco migrant pipeline
This week, Avery Haines follows migrants' harrowing journeys across the Darien Gap. Strict new rules to stem the flood of migrants through the notorious stretch of dense jungle appear to be working, but advocates fear it could backfire.
Supplies rushed to communities isolated by Helene as U.S. death toll rises to nearly 100
North Carolina officials pledged to get more water and other supplies to flood-stricken areas by Monday after Hurricane Helene left a trail of destruction across the U.S. Southeast and the death toll from the storm rose to nearly 100.
NEW What are the top baby names? Statistics Canada releases new list
If you're struggling to find a name for your baby, you can get some ideas from a new list of popular names.
John Ashton, 'Beverly Hills Cop' actor, dies at 76
John Ashton, the veteran character actor who memorably played the gruff but lovable police detective John Taggart in the 'Beverly Hills Cop' films, has died. He was 76.
What is open and closed this National Day for Truth and Reconciliation
This Monday, Sept. 30 is the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation, a federal statutory holiday and day of remembrance for the Indigenous children who never came home from Canadian residential schools, as well as those who survived them.
Earth will have a temporary 'mini moon' for 2 months
The space rock — 2024 PT5 — was first spotted in August by astronomers at Complutense University of Madrid using a powerful telescope located in Sutherland, South Africa.
Hezbollah says it is ready for any Israeli land invasion in Lebanon
Hezbollah's deputy leader Naim Qassem, in his first public address since Israel assassinated the group's chief last week, said the movement is ready to confront any Israeli ground invasion of Lebanon.
Ontario pedestrian dies after being struck by OPP vehicle
A pedestrian has died after reportedly getting struck by an OPP cruiser in Bala early Sunday morning.
Rustad wants B.C. Indigenous rights law repealed. Chief sees that as 40-year setback
British Columbia saw a rare unanimous vote in its legislature in October 2019, when members passed a law adopting the United Nations Declarations on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, setting out standards including free, prior and informed consent for actions affecting them.