Saskatoon judge rules child can receive COVID-19 vaccine in court battle between parents
A Saskatoon judge has ruled in favor of allowing a father to have his child vaccinated for COVID-19 despite the mother being opposed to her child getting the vaccine.
"I have determined the best interest of this child operate in favour of an order directing that the father shall be entitled to have the child vaccinated for the COVID-19 virus," wrote Justice Michael T. Megaw in his Sept. 9 decision.
The case centered around a mother and father who had opposing views on whether their 12-year-old daughter should be vaccinated.
The names of the plaintiffs and defendant have been redacted from court documents to protect the identity of the child at the centre of the application.
Court documents show in 2014, following a divorce, it was determined the children would live with their mother with their father getting specified parenting time. The mother would have final decision-making authority over education and medical matters regarding the children.
The child’s father applied for an order authorizing him to proceed with getting the young girl vaccinated as he was concerned the she was more at risk of contracting COVID-19 because of her diabetic condition.
But her mother opposed vaccinating the child because she said her daughter indicated she did not want to be vaccinated, and felt her voice should be heard. A psychotherapist concluded the child’s views should be respected and the child should be allowed to decline being vaccinated.
The mother also had general concerns about information circulated by health authorities regarding the vaccine and that the child may have a medical condition called "vaccine toxicity."
Both parents filed several submissions in support of their arguments.
The judge decided based on the evidence presented, the child’s diabetic condition didn’t place her at any greater risk than others with respect to the effects of getting COVID-19.
An affidavit from an anaesthesiologist following a video conference with the child said it appeared she had already suffered from vaccine toxicity issues.
But the judge noted the doctor diagnosed ‘possible’ vaccine toxicity and therefore his thoughts were not definitive.
In regards to the wishes of the child, the father questioned whether the child’s views were truly her own, and asserted the child’s wishes "do not simply carry the day on these matters."
The judge decided the child’s views need to be considered, but do not decide the issue. The judge also said there was concern about how much the child was influenced.
The father presented affidavits from three doctors while mother submitted affidavits from two doctors touching on the issue.
The judge accepted the information from the doctors who recommended getting the vaccine saying they were more qualified in the area of infectious disease and COVID-19.
“I have determined there is nothing before me that satisfies me on a balance of probabilities that this child’s health will be compromised by the administration of the COVID-19 vaccine” the judge wrote in his decision.
Saskatoon Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
The Canadian government has quietly lifted its advisory against non-essential international travel, marking the first time since March 2020 that the notice has been lifted.
Search resumes for potential unmarked graves outside former hospital that treated Indigenous patients
A search prompted by ground-penetrating radar is resuming again on land in Edmonton that houses a former hospital where Indigenous patients suffered abuse.
Edward Rogers is out as board chair of Rogers Communications Inc., a move that comes as the latest development in a boardroom drama that has prompted the departure of a senior executive and the launch of an executive oversight committee.
Queen Elizabeth II spent a night in a hospital for checks this week after cancelling an official trip to Northern Ireland on medical advice, Buckingham Palace said Thursday. The palace said the 95-year-old monarch went to the private King Edward VII's Hospital in London on Wednesday for 'preliminary investigations.'
Canadian propane prices are skyrocketing alongside natural gas due, in large part, to growing demand from overseas markets, a price surge analysts say will have a big impact on rural Canadians this winter.
The FBI's Denver office said Thursday that remains found a day earlier in a Florida nature reserve are those of Brian Laundrie, who disappeared last month just days after his fiance Gabby Petito was reported missing.
It appears one B.C. hatchery program is off to a promising start, by the size of the Chinook salmon they’ve been pulling in from the Wannock River near Bella Bella.
The federal government has announced a suite of changes to the popular income and business support programs put in place during the pandemic and set to expire on Saturday. Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland reminded Canadians on Thursday that the measures were always intended to be 'temporary.'
A woman has been killed and a man injured Thursday after they were shot by a prop firearm at a movie set outside Santa Fe, authorities said.
The Saskatchewan government released a statement Thursday morning saying social media posts about ICU patient transfers should be “disregarded” following immense confusion among doctors and officials over planned ICU patient transfers to Ontario.
Regina police have launched an investigation into the city’s 11th homicide of 2021.
The Saskatchewan government has confirmed that three additional ICU patients will be transferred to Ontario over the next three days, bringing the number of patients sent out of province to nine.
A doctor from Ste. Anne Manitoba is now facing 22 counts of sexual assault after police laid additional charges.
The number of direct-care workers in the province who are on unpaid leave continues to grow.
Following a manhunt that spanned two days, Manitoba RCMP arrested a suspect deemed a high risk to the general public.
Health officials identified 61 new cases of COVID-19 in the Vancouver Island region Thursday as hundreds of coronavirus cases remain active in the region.
An expected 'cyclone bomb' has emergency responders bracing for an increase in activity as the storm moves onto Vancouver Island Thursday and into the weekend.
A whale-watching guide on Vancouver Island has been fined thousands of dollars for getting too close to a pod of orcas.
Embattled Calgary Coun. Sean Chu said during a press conference on Thursday that he will not resign.
Election officials have denied four separate requests for recounts for Monday's civic election, including in Ward 4, the race that re-elected Coun. Sean Chu.
The man wanted in the accused homicide of Calgary's John Smith is now in police custody.
Capacity limits on restaurants and gyms in Ontario could be lifted next Monday, as the Ford government considers new measures for establishments that require proof of vaccination certificates, sources say.
Nephew of former 'Dragons' Den' star who 'inadvertently' shot and killed best friend pleads guilty to manslaughter
A Caledon man has pleaded guilty to manslaughter after he accidentally shot and killed his best friend with a machine gun at his uncle’s home in 2018.
Prayers and pain at funeral for 17-year-old girl killed crossing intersection near Scarborough school
Her death is being described as an excruciating loss. The emotion during the service, held at the Islamic Research Centre of Canada, was overwhelming and raw.
Brett O'Grady, 35, was reported missing on Thursday, Oct. 14. He was last seen in the area of Avro Circle in the east end.
Ottawa Hospital set to place more than 300 employees on unpaid leave for violating vaccination policy
More than 300 Ottawa Hospital employees who aren’t fully vaccinated against COVID-19 will be placed on an unpaid leave of absence as of Nov. 1.
The day after both case-count and death-rate averages rose in B.C., the province's health ministry announced hundreds more cases of COVID-19.
A B.C. supreme court judge has granted the province’s request for a permanent injunction against Rolly's Restaurant in Hope, which remained open and continued to serve customers despite having its business and liquor licences suspended on Oct. 7, for not checking vaccine passports.
Customers hoping to book a sailing on the BC Ferries website were out of luck Thursday afternoon, after the company experienced “technical difficulties.”
A doctor and McGill professor stopped in a no-parking zone in Mount-Royal on Tuesday. It ended with police entering his home, handcuffing him and dragging him out the door in front of his daughters, he says.
An Indigenous land acknowledgement from the Montreal Canadiens last week sent shockwaves through Quebec, with bipartisan backlash from politicians who called the Habs' statement false.
Local and provincial police officers recovered four guns during a raid in a residence in Ville St-Laurent, a borough in northern Montreal.
Alberta county star Corb Lund is not backing down on his fight against coal mining in Alberta’s eastern slopes - as he enlisted some help in a new protest video.
A 5.0 magnitude earthquake shook central Alberta Wednesday night.
Alberta reported 770 new cases of COVID-19 Thursday as pressure on the health care system starts to ease.
N.B. reports 2 more deaths related to COVID-19 as death toll surpasses 100; extends circuit-breaker for 7 days
Two more New Brunswickers have died as a result of COVID-19, raising the death toll in the province to 101 since the pandemic began. The province also extended circuit breaker measures for seven days.
Health officials in Nova Scotia are reporting 19 new cases of COVID-19 and 21 recoveries on Thursday, as the number of active cases in the province drops to 163.
Two Nova Scotia students who spent eight months fighting to be repaid rent after they departed their mouse-infested apartment say their case emphasizes the need for legal reforms to protect tenants.
A group of community advocates plan to gather outside Sault Ste. Marie city hall to demand action on the continuing overdose crisis in the city.
The Timmins Chamber of Commerce said it's receiving many calls from local businesses asking about the enforcement of vaccine passports and other COVID-19 health regulations.
Recognizing a need for wellness and a culture change in medicine, the Northern Ontario School of Medicine is offering a course titled 'Self-Compassion for Healthcare Communities.'
Sarnia, Ont.’s mayor is calling on the federal government to remove costly COVID-19 testing as a requirement for Canadians returning to Canada from the United States.
After a nearly two days of delays, Const. Stephen Williams tendered his resignation to the London Police Service effective Nov. 22.
A serious two-vehicle collision closed Highbury Avenue near Manning Drive on Thursday afternoon.