Saskatchewan pronoun policy doesn't do enough to mitigate harms, say legal professors
Saskatchewan legislation that requires parental consent when children under 16 change their names or pronouns at school fails to ensure gender-diverse youth aren't harmed, say two legal professors.
The Saskatchewan Party government tabled the bill with the notwithstanding clause last week, overriding sections of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Saskatchewan's Human Rights Code.
A judge granted an injunction at the end of September pausing the policy until a challenge could be heard in court later this year. The injunction prompted the government to invoke the clause to make sure the policy stays in place.
The legislation says if it's believed a student would be harmed because of the pronoun consent requirement, the school's principal is to direct the student to a counsellor. The counsellor would then develop a plan with the student to help them make a request to their parent to receive consent.
Robert Leckey, who teaches family law and is the dean at the faculty of law at McGill University, said such measure is inadequate.
He said even if children are provided counselling to develop a plan, their parents can still decide not to provide consent. This would either out children to their parents or stop teachers and school staff from using a child's chosen name or pronoun, resulting in harm.
"A harmful and dangerous policy has not somehow been saved by the exception," Leckey said. "I think it's narrow, and so I don't think the policy adequately takes account of the risks to children here."
Bruce Ryder, a law professor at York University specializing in human rights and constitutional law, said the measure is deficient.
"I think they know very well that the law is going to cause harm to students, and they're going ahead with it despite that knowledge," Ryder said.
"To me, that's part of the story that is most shocking."
When he granted the injunction, Justice Michael Megaw said it was necessary to prevent gender-diverse youth from experiencing "irreparable harm."
Education Minister Jeremy Cockrill told reporters last week the policy has strong support from the majority of Saskatchewan residents and parents.
Cockrill said supports are available if a child believes they may be harmed.
"If there's perceived or potential harm, there's an explicit expectation on school staff to make sure that supports are provided, whether that's in the school context or referring to a community organization," he said.
Leckey said the policy seems to ignore family and child protection law, saying the guiding principle is to do what's in the best interest of the child.
He said parents have broad authority to educate their children, but there are limits.
"Normally we would think that parents' rights stop where the child's safety began," Leckey said.
"This is derogating from that principle, this is using the notwithstanding clause to override children's rights to self determination and freedom. It's very much creating a new right for parents and putting it in a paramount position. It's quite a serious proposal."
Ryder said the government could have achieved a reasonable balance between the rights of parents and children.
He said the legislation could have included exceptions for mature minors, who are children under 16 able to make health decisions for themselves.
It could have also included exemptions for children who would face serious harm, he added.
"Reasonable process, I think, would always seek to involve the parents as a default position, but would measure first the risk of harm. And if the risk of harm is particularly great, there should be an exemption from the parental consent requirements," he said.
The legislation includes a clause that aims to prevent people or organizations from suing the government, members of cabinet and school boards over the legislation, saying claims for losses or damages are to be "extinguished."
Leckey said this isn't the first time governments have put such clause in legislation.
He said people could still sue the government, but that it would be difficult to seek damages once the policy is enacted.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 15, 2023.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW Inside Canada's chaotic response to avian flu
A CFIA official is calling it the 'largest animal health emergency that this country has ever had to face.' A joint IJF/CTV News investigation looks into Canada's response to the bird flu pandemic, and how it's ravaged the country's farms.
What Donald Trump's election victory could mean for Canada
Following president-elect Donald Trump's decisive election victory, there are sure to be significant knock-on effects for Canada. Here's a look at the different areas in which a second Trump presidency may affect Canadians.
Cuba left reeling after Category 3 hurricane ravages island and knocks out power grid
Cuba was left reeling Thursday after a fierce Category 3 hurricane ripped across the island and knocked out the country's power grid.
The world's 10 richest people got a record US$64 billion richer from Trump's re-election
Wednesday wasn't just a good day for Donald Trump. The wealth of the world’s 10 richest people also soared by a record amount, according to Bloomberg’s Billionaire Index.
Influencer is banned from future NYC marathons for bringing a camera crew to last weekend's race
A social media influencer from Texas was disqualified from last weekend's New York City Marathon and banned from future competitions after he ran the race with a camera crew on e-bikes in tow.
Sleepy during the day? You may be at higher risk for a pre-dementia syndrome, study finds
If you find yourself sleepy during your daily activities in your older age, you may need to consider it more than an inconvenience — since the fatigue may indicate you’re at higher risk for developing a condition that can lead to dementia, a new study has found.
Kamala Harris concedes: Here's what she said in her speech
Democratic Vice-President Kamala Harris conceded the U.S. election to Republican Donald Trump Wednesday afternoon, telling her supporters that her 'heart is full.'
Canada's health-care spending expected to outpace economy in 2024: CIHI
The Canadian Institute for Health Information says health-care spending in Canada is projected to reach a new high in 2024.
Newfoundland hockey player suspended, banned from local arena after off-ice fight with fan
A combination of a thrown stick and thrown punches have given a senior hockey player in Newfoundland a three-game suspension and an indefinite ban from one of his league's six arenas.