'Rubbernecking': Regina man acquitted in brutal group beating in max unit of Sask. penitentiary
A Regina man accused of aggravated assault in the brutal beating of an inmate in the maximum security wing of the Saskatchewan Penitentiary was acquitted this month.
In his written decision, Judge Richard Danyliuk drew on 17th Century English philosopher Thomas Hobbes to describe life in the max unit of the Prince Albert-based facility as “nasty, brutish and short.”
Joshua Bird was one of several inmates accused in the assault of Elwin Goodpipe, who was found beaten in his cell on Oct. 7, 2019 and taken to hospital for treatment.
According to Danyliuk, Goodpipe refused to cooperate with police in their investigation.
“Mr. Goodpipe did not want the police involved, refused to give any statement, and was generally uncooperative. Cst. Schmidt noted fairly severe head injuries to Mr. Goodpipe and that his head was very swollen as well as one arm being fractured. Mr. Goodpipe would not allow himself to be photographed,” the judge wrote in his March 1 decision.
With no participation from the victim, the Crown relied heavily on surveillance footage from outside the cell during the trial at the Prince Albert Court of King’s Bench, Danyliuk said.
In the footage, court saw Goodpipe enter his cell, followed by Bird and three other inmates. Bird stood with his hand on the jamb, only entering the cell briefly by a step or two for about eight seconds.
The Crown also submitted photos of Goodpipe’s cell into evidence.
“There was a very large amount of bloodstains in the cell,” wrote Danyliuk. “Most of the blood was on or near the bunk. However, he noted blood transfers of numerous types on all four walls, the floor, and even the ceiling. The photographs graphically depict and reflect what appears to have been a savage beating.”
In his defence, Bird testified that the group was playing cards in the common area when a dispute arose between Goodpipe and another inmate. When that inmate followed Goodpipe into his cell, Bird told the court he followed because he was hoping to see a one-on-one fight.
“Knowing about the range cameras and how they operated, Mr. Bird said he stayed in the doorway of the Goodpipe cell and did not enter except briefly. He said he kept his hand on the doorjamb so that it could be seen he was not going all the way into the cell. He testified he never fully entered the cell and took no active part in the assault on Mr. Goodpipe,” Danyliuk wrote.
“However, he watched Mr. Goodpipe being beaten into unconsciousness.”
Bird said he assumed the guards would see the men inside Goodpipe’s cell and intervene — just entering another inmate’s cell is a rule infraction in federal prison.
He testified that he did not want to actively alert the guards because it would “come back on him. He would get labelled as a ‘rat’ and would get stabbed.”
The Crown was trying to make the case that Bird was an active participant in the beating, and not just a spectator, as he contended.
But Danyliuk said the only evidence available as to Bird’s intention in standing at the entrance to Goodpipe’s cell was from Bird himself.
“The Crown called none of the other assailants, nor the victim,” he wrote.
“The Crown has failed to prove what Mr. Bird did or refrained from doing that assisted the other three inmates to effect the beating of Mr. Goodpipe.”
Ultimately, Danyliuk says he was left with a reasonable doubt that Bird intended to participate in the beating.
“He was, to borrow defence counsel’s phrasing, engaged in ‘rubbernecking’ — watching, in other words, and watching in and of itself is not a crime.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Deadly six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 sparked by road rage incident
One person was killed in a six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 in Innisfil Friday evening.
'Of course, yes': Poland latest European country with interest in Canadian LNG
The President of Poland says his country would 'of course' be interested in purchasing Canadian liquefied natural gas if it were available, while the Canadian federal government has said it is 'not interested' in subsidizing future projects.
Dozens in Italy give a fascist salute on the anniversary of Mussolini's execution
Dozens of people raised their arms in the fascist salute and shouted a fascist chant during ceremonies Sunday to honor Italian dictator Benito Mussolini on the 79th anniversary of his execution.
Here's where Canadians are living abroad: report
A recent report sheds light on Canadians living abroad--estimated at around four million people in 2016—and the public policies that impact them.
Chants of 'shame on you' greet guests arriving for the annual White House correspondents' dinner
An election-year roast of U.S. President Joe Biden before journalists, celebrities and politicians at the annual White House correspondents' dinner Saturday.
Britney Spears settles long-running legal dispute with estranged father, finally bringing ultimate end to conservatorship
Britney Spears has reached a settlement with her estranged father more than two years after the court-ordered termination of a conservatorship that had given him control of her life, their attorneys said.
Invasive and toxic hammerhead worms make themselves at home in Ontario
Ontario is now home to an invasive and toxic worm species that can grow up to three feet long and can be dangerous to small animals and pets.
Health minister 'deeply appreciative' of doctors but capital gains changes here to stay
Health Minister Mark Holland says while he is 'deeply appreciative' of the work doctors in Canada do, the federal government has no plans to scrap the proposed capital gains tax changes outlined in the latest budget, despite opposition from the Canadian Medical Association.
A top Qatari official urges Israel and Hamas to do more to reach a ceasefire deal
A senior Qatari official has urged both Israel and Hamas to show "more commitment and more seriousness" in ceasefire negotiations in interviews with Israeli media, as pressure builds on both sides to move toward a deal that would set Israeli hostages free and bring potential respite in the nearly seven-month-long war in Gaza.