Saskatoon group caught with kilos of meth is back on trial after judge overturns acquittal
A man and woman in Saskatoon who had two kilograms of methamphetamine seized from a home are going back to trial after having their acquittals overturned.
The Saskatoon Police Service received information that Thomas James Arendt and Kayleigha Shaneih Anneleise Bear may be involved in drug trafficking in 2022. They began surveillance of Arendt’s home, observed several short meetings with him and visitors, and applied for a search warrant based on that information.
When their application was rejected, the officer applying for the warrant — the affiant — revised the application based on the shortcomings described by the judge, and resubmitted. After getting the warrant, police searched the home and found about two kilograms of methamphetamine, cash and paraphernalia.
Arendt and Bear were later acquitted of the charges when a judge reviewed the warrant application and found Saskatoon police had fabricated details about the suspects that didn’t match the surveillance logs they were drawn from.
As a result, the seized drugs weren’t admissible as evidence, and the two were acquitted of the charges. The Crown lawyers appealed that judgment in April.
Now, three justices on Saskatchewan’s highest court have sided with the Crown.
While they agreed there were clear issues with the warrant, Justice Brian Barrington-Foote writes the judge overstepped his limited role in reviewing the warrant application. More than just removing inaccuracies, the reviewing judge went so far as determining the affiant was not an accurate witness.
By comparing the surveillance logs to what was written in the warrant application, reviewing judge Quentin Agnew found the police were overstating their evidence by including elements that were “entirely fictional,” including a description of one person emerging from Arendt’s house, hunched over and manipulating what police believed to be drugs.
“This ‘observation’ has no basis in the evidence, and accordingly, neither does the commentary,” Agnew wrote.
In their application, police alluded to previous drug trafficking and weapons charges against Arendt, even though he was acquitted or received a stay of proceedings on those counts — no convictions.
Agnew also took issue with the way police phrased their observations to imply guilt, without reference to further evidence.
“The weakness of the affiant’s evidence, in referring to events ‘believed to be’ or ‘consistent with’ drug transactions, and the weakness of assertions based on the affiant’s ‘experience as a police officer and drug investigator’ without further explanation” cast the entire application into doubt, Agnew wrote.
However, the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal says it wasn’t Agnew’s role to determine the overall credibility of the investigators, simply to remove portions of the warrant application that were inaccurate.
“He mistakenly held that it fell to him as the reviewing judge to determine whether the affiant and the evidence remaining after the excisions were reliable,” Barrington-Foote said.
“By doing so, he substituted his view for that of the issuing judge,” he said.
“I am persuaded that, absent the legal error, he may well have reached a different bottom-line conclusion.”
Since Arendt and Bear were acquitted after Agnew deemed the seized drugs inadmissible as evidence, the decision of the appeal court means their acquittals have been overturned and they’re heading back to trial.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING 'A carbon tax election': MPs debate Conservative non-confidence motion in Liberal government
MPs in the House of Commons are debating the Conservatives’ non-confidence motion today, with Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre calling for 'a carbon tax election,' and a return to what he called 'the Canadian promise' in a 20-minute speech.
EXCLUSIVE Image released of mysterious object shot down over Yukon in 2023
An image of the unidentified object shot down over Canada's Yukon territory in February 2023 has been obtained by CTVNews.ca.
Couple in Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., awarded more than $500K for enduring life with hellish neighbour
We've all had neighbours we didn't like, but two people from Sault Ste. Marie have been awarded more than half a million dollars for the 'extreme' behaviour of the people who lived next to them.
Police arrest five people in Spain over fake Brad Pitt scam after two women lost US$362,000
Police in Spain have arrested five people accused of scamming two women out of 325,000 euros (US$362,000) by pretending to be Hollywood star Brad Pitt online.
Health Canada approves Pfizer-BioNTech's updated COVID-19 vaccine
Health Canada has approved Pfizer-BioNTech's updated COVID-19 vaccine that protects against one of the most recently circulating variants of the virus.
Canadians in Lebanon told to get out while flights available, don't wait for government evacuation
The federal government is advising Canadians in Lebanon to leave now while commercial flights are available, saying, 'Canada is not currently offering assisted departures or evacuations.'
Pro Football Hall of Fame quarterback Brett Favre has Parkinson's
Pro Football Hall of Fame quarterback Brett Favre revealed Tuesday at a hearing on federal welfare reform that he has been diagnosed with Parkinson's disease.
Ontario woman seen in viral video of Porsche theft now facing more charges
An 18-year-old woman who allegedly stole a Porsche and then ran over its owner in a caught-on-video incident in Mississauga earlier this month is now facing auto theft charges in Toronto.
Bank of Canada says it's reasonable to expect more rate cuts
Given the continued progress the Bank of Canada has made in bringing inflation back down to the 2 per cent target, it is reasonable to expect more rate cuts, Governor Tiff Macklem said on Tuesday.