Saskatoon an 'interesting battleground' as NDP grapples with Sask. Party dominance: expert
SASKATOON -- Saskatoon is going to be an “interesting battleground” between the Sask. Party and the NDP, political studies expert Loleen Berdahl says.
Notably, three incumbent NDP Saskatoon MLAs - Danielle Chartier, David Forbes and Cathy Sproule - aren’t running again.
“Anytime there’s an incumbent they’ve got a little bit of an advantage - they’ve got some name recognition just through the fact of already being the MLA, people have received communication from them over the years,” said Berdahl, executive director of the Johnson Shoyama Graduate School of Public Policy at the University of Saskatchewan and University of Regina.
“So the fact that there’s some seats that had been NDP that the incumbents aren’t running in, that becomes a more contested seat.”
Saskatoon also saw several close contests in 2016, with five ridings decided by single-digit percentage point margins. In the closest race, Saskatoon Westview, the Sask. Party’s David Buckingham won by 2.74 points - or just 217 votes.
- Saskatoon Meewasin. Winner: Roger Parent, Sask. Party. 50.5% of the vote (7.54 point margin)
- Saskatoon University. Winner: Eric Olauson, Sask. Party. 48% (5.43 points)
- Saskatoon Riversdale. Winner: Danielle Chartier, NDP. 48.2% (4.64 points)
- Saskatoon Fairview. Winner: Jennifer Campeau, Sask Party. 48.2% (2.98 points)
- Saskatoon Westview. Winner: David Buckingham, Sask. Party. 49.1% (2.74 points)
Polling data suggest the economy and health care, including the COVID-19 pandemic, will be important factors for voters, with education coming in third, she said.
The data also points to a re-election of the Sask. Party. A University of Saskatchewan poll found it leading the NDP among decided voters three-to-one. Much would need to change to see a change in government, she said.
“In Canada we tend to talk about natural governing parties. At the federal level, there’s this idea that the Liberal Party is the natural governing party, they’re the default party. In Saskatchewan politics, we used to talk about the NDP as being the natural governing party. That really seems to have shifted quite dramatically since the mid-2000s. There's been a really strong shift in the default political culture.
“I think the distinction that used to be drawn in terms of politics and values between Saskatchewan and Alberta has perhaps shifted a bit over time. So when we look at attitudinal surveys, we see these sorts of patterns. I think the Saskatchewan Party has enjoyed a lot of support because they’ve gained the confidence of a significant portion of the electorate. They’ve certainly enjoyed periods of considerable prosperity when the resource economy was doing really well internationally but they've also enjoyed a fair bit of support even when things have been more challenging. There seems to be a comfort level that the public has.”
Assuming the province doesn’t see large shifts in attitudes, the outcome in the Saskatoon ridings will help determine how strong the NDP will be as an opposition party, Berdahl said.
“(NDP Leader) Ryan Meili’s own riding was a pretty tight contest in the by-election. He didn’t win by a massive landslide. So the future of the NDP in terms of its strength as a party is one question. Then there’s the question, what happens with the leadership of the party? Does Meili hold onto his own seat? If he doesn't, what will that mean?”
Changing the political attitudes of the province is a challenging question for the NDP, she said.
“What do they do? I think they’ve really struggled. They’ve struggled with turnover in leadership. This is their third campaign with a new leader. So that can become a challenge for them. This election is a very important one for the NDP in terms of how do they decide to move forward as a party? So I don’t have an answer," Berdahl said.
“I think it would be a great question to ask the NDP themselves - what’s the game plan going forward? The same question could very well be asked of the federal NDP. We’ve been seeing them declining as well. How do they regain their foothold, if they are going to?”