Why Saskatchewan has a publicly-funded Catholic school system
The Greater Saskatoon Catholic School board surprised and disappointed some with a leaked email this week, raising questions about the difference between public and Catholic schools in the province.
The Catholic school system in Saskatchewan has a long history and is ultimately protected by the province’s constitution — something the courts have backed up.
Historians point to the 1905 Saskatchewan Act, which is the first government document that indicates separate public and Catholic schools.
“It was also determined at that time that if you're going to have separate schools, you need to fund those schools,” executive director of the Catholic School Boards Association Tom Fortosky told CTV News.
“Essentially what [the Saskatchewan Act] says is that if the government provides any funding to public or separate schools ... they cannot discriminate between public and separate schools.”
He said that meant it has to be equivalent funding.
“Property taxes were the main funder of schools at that time. The government also provided grants to schools. So what the Catholic community wanted is protections for the separate school rights.”
The Catholic community was concerned about what happened to the east.
“What happened in Manitoba in the 1890s is that … (constitutional protection for) Catholic education was lost,” Fortosky said.
“They were very concerned that unless they got the approval or some constitutional protections in the new Saskatchewan Act, they thought they might actually lose it the same way that it was lost in Manitoba.”
During the creation of the province, Catholics put their foot down in a demand for Catholic schools.
“It was after a lot of discussion and negotiation argumentation, that the constitutional rights were protected in the constitution of Saskatchewan, and also the funding piece was protected in the constitution. So that's how it all got in.”
THE SASKATCHEWAN ACT OF 1905
Just before the Saskatchewan Act was introduced, the education system in Canada underwent some changes.
“In 1892, they create more or less a Department of Education, a single department of education that oversees public and separate schools. And that system that was created in 1892 is confirmed in 1901. So single board of education you can have, it supports both public and separate schools,” author and historian Bill Weiser told CTV News.
It was Wilfrid Laurier that introduced the Saskatchewan Act, which ended up being a political battleground.
“The debate in the House of Commons is so acrimonious over this about what is Laurier up to? What's he trying to do? That the debate delays the entry of Saskatchewan and Alberta into Confederation until September 1, 1905,” Weiser said.
“One of the sad things about this episode is that not only does the entry of these provinces get sullied by this very acrimonious debate over the educational system, but what also gets lost in 1905 is that Saskatchewan and Alberta were treated differently, unlike all other provinces at the time, according to the 1905 legislation, they would not get control over their public lands and resources.”
Weiser said the plans for Saskatchewan at the time were very Anglo driven.
“There was this emphasis after 1885 on the British character of the region. So there were Catholic concerns at the time,” he said.
“There is a real strain of anti-Catholicism in the early 20th century.”
THE THEODORE CASE
The Catholic school system was challenged about two decades ago in a Saskatchewan court, and it was a battle that took almost 20 years to settle.
At the time the court decision came down, John Whyte was the Deputy Minister of Justice.
“What they [prosecutors] were saying was that what was being protected constitutionally was publicly-funded Catholic education for Catholics. Not a publicly funded Catholic, organized and managed education system, the difference being that the system that was constantly protected in the development of provincial autonomy was Catholic education for Catholics,” Whyte said.
“The high Court of Queen's Bench of Saskatchewan said what was protected was Catholic education for Catholics.”
The decision would mean non-Catholics would not be funded to attend Catholic schools.
“The Court of Appeal decided that the agreement in the Confederation in the period that provinces were created, and the agreement that was put in place in the 1905 Saskatchewan Act, is an agreement that guarantees school funding for Catholic schools, meaning schools that are run by the Catholic church, schools that embody Catholic principles, and Catholic administration. It doesn't have to be one which is available to Catholics.”
Whyte said the Supreme Court of Canada declined to hear the case.
“That case was never reversed," he said. "And that's what we have now.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau offered 'unreserved apologies' Wednesday for Parliament's recognition of a man who fought for a Nazi unit during the Second World War and said the Canadian government has reached out to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in the wake of the incident.
U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan said Wednesday she won't recuse herself from Donald Trump's 2020 election interference case in Washington, rejecting the former president's claims that her past comments raise doubts about whether she can be fair.
IED believed to be on vehicle in Barrie, Ont. parking lot explodes, sparking evacuations and road closures
Police have locked down and evacuated a section of Barrie, Ont., Wednesday morning in the city's west end amid unconfirmed reports of an explosion.
Prevention could have prevented nearly seven in 10 premature cancer deaths among women worldwide in 2020, new research has found.
Dozens of people faced criminal charges Wednesday after a night of social media-fueled mayhem in which groups of thieves, apparently working together, smashed their way into stores in several areas of Philadelphia, stuffing plastic bags with merchandise and fleeing, authorities said.
The studio lights are going dark at 'ET Canada.' Corus Entertainment says it has decided to cease production on the long-running Canadian arts and entertainment news magazine after 18 seasons.
Law enforcement agencies have denied allegations that a dispute over jurisdiction delayed the investigation into the murder of Surrey, B.C., Sikh leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar.
Indigenous Services Minister Patty Hajdu says she hopes to table a piece of legislation this fall that she says is the closest the federal government has come to co-developing law with First Nations.
Streaming platform Disney+ is updating its subscriber agreement and is adding a no-sharing-passwords policy.
It has become common to hear a land acknowledgement at the beginning of any event or meeting. However, some people believe it is time to put the words into action.
The fences around Regina's city hall courtyard will be removed, according to city manager Niki Anderson.
A Winnipeg man has pleaded guilty to manslaughter and theft of a motor vehicle in connection to the 2021 death of Saskatchewan RCMP Officer Shelby Patton.
Another blockade leading to the Brady Landfill has appeared as conversations around searching the Prairie Green Landfill for the remains of two Indigenous women continues in the province.
Manitoba's Progressive Conservatives are continuing to be dogged by mounting disapproval for taking out billboard and newspaper ads that highlights the province's decision not to search a landfill for the remains of two First Nations women.
A Winnipeg man is facing several charges in connection with a fatal hit-and-run in St. Vital on Tuesday night.
Calgary police took one person into custody on Wednesday after a shooting outside the Calgary International Airport.
Someone stole a puppy.
The Calgary Flames have signed centre Mikael Backlund to a two-year contract extension, and named him the 21st team captain in franchise history.
Edmonton police released suspect photos Wednesday as officers investigate a hate-motivated mischief case that happened during the local "1MillionMarch4Children" protest last week.
A dog on a ranch near Barrhead, Alta., is feline fine about mothering abandoned kittens.
Ground was broken Wednesday on a transitional housing project on Fort Road in Edmonton, a place the leader of the Dene Tha' First Nation hopes will soon become a launchpad for big accomplishments by Treaty 8 youth.
The provincial government is reviewing how workplace safety claims filed by seasonal farm workers are handled following a years-long appeal by four Jamaican migrants who were permanently injured on the job.
A 10-year-old girl has died after being struck by a vehicle north of Toronto Wednesday afternoon.
Prosecutors at the sexual assault trial of fashion magnate Peter Nygard played a promotional video illustrating his building on Niagara Street in downtown Toronto, as it appeared when it was occupied by Nygard's business, including the private bedroom on the top floor where the assaults allegedly took place.
The Ottawa Mission has received a donation of some high-end food from a party at the Speaker of the House's official residence, which was cancelled at the last minute when Anthony Rota resigned.
Cine Starz Orléans confirms to CTV News Ottawa the lease for the Orléans location ended in June, and the theatre permanently closed on Tuesday after talks with the management company to extend the lease ended.
Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band announced Wednesday afternoon that all 2023 tour dates will be postponed until 2024 as Springsteen continues to recover from peptic ulcer disease.
Some health-care workers in British Columbia have started receiving notification that they will once again be expected to wear masks in medical settings, but the language is ambiguous about what exactly will be required and for whom.
Residents living at the bottom of Vancouver’s steepest street say it’s becoming increasingly dangerous, and they’re calling on the city to install traffic lights before someone is seriously hurt.
A senior investigator at Vancouver City Savings Credit Union says a bank account registered to Ibrahim Ali shows transactions in Burnaby, B.C., on July 18, 2017, the same day a 13-year-old was murdered in a city park.
The older brother of a mentally ill man who killed three people at random during a 24-hour shooting spree in the Montreal area last year told a coroner Wednesday he questions why his medication regime had been changed before the killings.
Police said Wednesday evening they have opened a double homicide investigation after the bodies of two women were found in an apartment on Montreal's South Shore.
Quebec's police watchdog has opened an investigation after a man was shot by police after he allegedly pointed his gun at them during an intervention. Media reports say the man who was shot allegedly made threats against Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Quebec Premier Francois Legault.
The B.C. Ministry of Health says a proposed bylaw change by the body that regulates doctors could allow physician assistants to work in provincial emergency rooms.
After significant rainfall in some regions of Vancouver Island, the British Columbia government is rescinding water restrictions for the Koksilah and Tsolum river watersheds.
Southbound traffic into downtown Victoria was disrupted for several hours Wednesday after a dump rolled onto its side on the Pat Bay Highway.
Will they or won't they?: Speculation grows over the possibility of a fall election in New Brunswick
It's a question of will they won't they when it comes to calling an election this fall in New Brunswick
Sixteen dogs who were evacuated from Hay River, N.W.T., after wildfires devastated the town, have been taken in by the Nova Scotia SPCA.
Nova Scotia's Progressive Conservative government is joining with Ottawa to fund 222 public housing units as the province battles an ongoing shortage of affordable residences.
A drug dealer from Manitoulin Island has been declared a dangerous offender after being convicted of more sex crimes against children.
The president of a college in North Bay, Ont., says a recent protest at the school that saw students sleeping in tents was a “publicity stunt” organized by an outside group.
There was no hustle and bustle outside of Nipissing-Timiskaming MP Anthony Rota’s North Bay constituency office on Wednesday.
Toronto Maple Leafs rookie Easton Cowan couldn’t believe the size of the crowd when the team bus pulled up to the Joe Thornton Community Centre in St. Thomas, Ont.
Warning graphic: 'Multiple trauma': Causes of death of London truck attack victims confirmed in terrorism trial
A Windsor jury heard another agreed statement of facts Wednesday in the ongoing trial of Nathaniel Veltman, 22.
Marie Andree Sanon of London, Ont. won a prize worth $1-million in Lotto 6/49’S Gold Ball Draw on Aug. 23, 2023.