How a tax on $1M homes across Canada could pay off in Sask.
Paul Kershaw worries that while Canada’s economy is more prosperous than ever, younger generations are struggling with lower earnings, higher costs, growing debts and a deteriorating environment. That's why Kershaw, the founder of Generation Squeeze, proposes putting a price on housing inequity by adding a surtax (starting at 0.2 per cent and peaking at 1 per cent) on home value over $1 million in order to slow down home prices so earnings have a chance to catch up.
He spoke with CTV News at Five anchor Matt Young to defend the idea and explain why Saskatchewan residents should embrace it. This interview has been edited for length and clarity. The entire interview can be watched using the player above.
I don't know of many times putting a tax on something actually helps the prices go down. Usually, from what I've seen, you put a tax on something, the price goes up. How can you think in this case it would bring housing prices down?
That's a great question. And so first of all, what we're proposing is a surtax on home values only over $1 million. That would apply to only 10 per cent of Canadian households in the country, which means 90 per cent wouldn't pay any more. And since most of the homes over a million bucks are concentrated in B.C. and Ontario, we're actually proposing something that would have almost no impact in terms of paying more in the province of Saskatchewan.
Actually, Saskatchewan is going to be a place that likes this idea because our overarching argument is that when it comes to reducing housing unaffordability and wealth inequality, we need to start protecting real shelters more than tax shelters. Your listeners might be wondering, "what do you mean, tax shelter?" For any listener today, if you went to work 100 per cent of your earnings are going to be taxed. If you invest some of those earnings in the stock market, 50 per cent of any return on your investment will be subject to tax. But by contrast, the wealth gained in somebody's principal residence is barely going to be taxed at all.
I understand that, but still, I mean I fail to see how this lowers home prices. Your own report says there is a risk that homeowners would just pass that cost down to renters. And quite frankly, if you're a homeowner and you're selling a home and you're looking at a $10,000 tax bill, you're just going to raise the price to recover that.
Because you have to think about how tax shelters work. We all know that there are offshore tax shelters and (they) frustrate us. They motivate Canadians to move money offshore in order to preserve assets, so we're incentivized by tax rules to move our money.
When we have homeownership tax shelters as I described at the beginning of the interview, it incentivizes Canadians to bank on high and rising home prices. And the moment that our policy system turns homeownership into an investment strategy, we entangle those owners and hope that home prices will rise beyond local earnings. The moment we build that hope into our housing system, we tolerate (higher) home prices and that is what's crushing affordability and harming younger and future generations. And so our (proposed) tax is designed to address at the system level to change people's wants and hopes for what we expect of housing prices.
The report suggests that there could be some trouble getting some political support for this. That's a lot of lobbying political risk, potentially, for a federal government. Can I ask you about that?
Yeah, that's a great question. We didn't put out this proposal anticipating there would be any party ready to jump on it right away. We actually really are in a competition for the hearts and minds of Canadians. What do we want from housing? Do we want housing to be a place to call home? Or do we want housing to be a way to make really good money?
Second, people in Saskatchewan I think should be, "Yeah!" because … we don't see the same price escalation. Way to go. Let's celebrate affordability. Our work pays off more in your province than it does in B.C. or Ontario, especially for young people.
So we are saying, let's try and compete for people to reorient ourselves and what we want to do, by talking about this tax. We know it'll get some people angry early on, but I hope in Saskatchewan the listeners there say, wait, you're talking about not taxing me more, trying to improve housing affordability in other parts of the country and raise some revenue that might result in building deeply affordable cooperative and rental housing in my communities - that sounds great. And then we can try and build some political cover for our politicians to be courageous to address the reality that the skyrocketing gap between home prices and earnings is just killing the way that hard work pays off for people, especially young people in many parts of the country.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Why drivers in Eastern Canada could see big gas price spikes, and other Canadians won't
Drivers in Eastern Canada face a big increase in gas prices because of various factors, especially the higher cost of the summer blend, industry analysts say.
How to avoid the trap of becoming 'house poor'
The journey to home ownership can be exciting, but personal finance columnist Christopher Liew warns about the trappings of becoming 'house poor' -- where an overwhelming portion of your income is devoured by housing costs. Liew offers some practical strategies to maintain better financial health while owning a home.
Toxic forever chemicals in drinking water: Is Canada doing enough?
As the United States sets its first national limits on toxic forever chemicals in drinking water, researchers say Canada is lagging when it comes to regulations.
'A living nightmare': Winnipeg woman sentenced following campaign of harassment against man after online date
A Winnipeg woman was sentenced to house arrest after a single date with a man she met online culminated in her harassing him for years, and spurred false allegations which resulted in the innocent man being arrested three times.
Some customers steaming after McDonald's ends free hot drink sticker program
It took years for Vinnie Deluca to collect more than 400 cards worth of free McDonald's McCafe coffee, a collection that now has "zero value" after the company discontinued the program.
Biden scores endorsements from Kennedy family, looking to shore up support against Trump and RFK Jr.
U.S. President Joe Biden will accept endorsements from at least 15 members of the Kennedy political family during a campaign stop in Philadelphia on Thursday as he aims to undermine Donald Trump and marginalize the candidacy of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Where did the gold go? Crime expert weighs in on unfolding Pearson airport heist investigation
Almost 7,000 bars of pure gold were stolen from Pearson International Airport exactly one year ago during an elaborate heist, but so far only a tiny fraction of that stolen loot has been found.
When new leaders took over in ancient Maya, they didn't just bury the former royals. They burned their bodies in public
New archeological investigations in Guatemala reveal that the ancient Maya people had a ritual of burning royal human remains as a public display of political regime change.
Party's over: Coyotes play final game as Arizona franchise before move to Salt Lake City
Mullett Arena buzzed like few times in the two years since the Arizona Coyotes moved in, the fans amped for one last desert hurrah.