Claim that a boat 'works awesome' doesn't count as a warranty, Sask. judge says
An attempt to claim damages for a boat that sputtered to a stop during its first outing didn't hold water with a Saskatoon judge.
The trouble began for a Saskatchewan man in June 2019, around 45 minutes into a day on Candle Lake — travelling in a boat he recently bought off Kijiji.
"It was a beautiful day and (the buyer) was excited to use his new boat," Provincial Court Judge Steven Schiefner wrote in a ruling issued earlier this month.
"He drove around the lake and ran the boat at various rates of speed including one short run at 95 (kilometres per hour)."
A "loud clicking noise" coming from the boat's engine signalled a change in fortunes for the man and his family.
He shut down the motor to try and find the source of the problem. The boat wouldn't restart and required a tow back to shore.
He had purchased the boat on April 4, 2019 from a man who lived on an acreage located near Silton, Sask.
The online ad for the black, 21-foot, 2008 Baja Islander touted features such as its 350 MAG engine, swim deck, Clarion stereo and its special order "outlaw graphics."
The ad said the boat "works awesome."
While it wasn't possible to submerge it in a lake, the seller provided a source of water so the motor could be tested, the decision said.
A day later the buyer and his wife returned to purchase the boat, adding a line in the bill of sale saying the seller "guarantees" the boat, motor and accessories are in "good working order" and that no information has been withheld regarding its condition.
Based on the language used in the ad, which also used the phrase "mint condition," and the additional lines in the bill of sale, the seller thought there was a case to be made for compensation.
After his family's day on the lake was stalled, he spent roughly $1,300 repairing the watercraft.
Schiefner disagreed. He said words such as "awesome" amount to "little more than advertising puffery."
"Even though 'mint' means in near-perfect condition, as if never touched or used, the seller's advertisement was clear the boat had been both touched and used — for 10 years."
Schiefner also was not swayed by the clause included in the bill of sale.
He acknowledged the common legal standard for second-hand sales, caveat emptor — better known as "let the buyer beware" — was "modified" by the added condition.
However, he said other than another "minor" problem found when the boat was repaired, the evidence showed it was "functioning properly" when it was sold.
The guarantee "did not warranty the boat was free from latent defects," Schiefner wrote.
The "progressive crack" in a gear that caused the motor to fail "could have lasted for 10 years during which time the boat would have functioned properly," Schiefner wrote, referencing information provided by a repair shop during the trial.
"Unfortunately ... it only lasted 45 minutes."
Schiefner dismissed the claim and said ultimately the buyer should bear the loss because he knew he was buying a used boat.
In addition to repair costs, the buyer was seeking damages for the "loss of use and enjoyment of the boat."
He estimated he would have taken the boat out six to eight times over the time it was in the shop. The cost of a replacement boat would have been $380 per day.
The scenario was entirely hypothetical as he never actually rented a boat, according to the decision.
Based on this, Schiefner wrote that even if he had found in the buyer's favour, he would not have awarded damages for "loss of enjoyment."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Poilievre will do 'anything to win,' must condemn Alex Jones endorsement: Trudeau
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is ramping up his attacks on Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre as he promotes his government's federal budget.
'My stomach dropped': Winnipeg man speaks out after being criminally harassed following single online date
A Winnipeg man said a single date gone wrong led to years of criminal harassment, false arrests, stress and depression.
New evidence challenges the Pentagon's account of a horrific attack as the U.S. withdrew from Afghanistan: CNN exclusive
New video evidence uncovered by CNN significantly undermines two Pentagon investigations into an ISIS-K suicide attack outside Kabul airport, during the American withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021.
'One of the single most terrifying things ever': Ontario couple among passengers on sinking tour boat in Dominican Republic
A Toronto couple are speaking out about their 'extremely dangerous' experience on board a sinking tour boat in the Dominican Republic last week.
All Alberta wildfires to date in 2024 believed to be human-caused: province
There are 63 wildfires burning in Alberta's forest protection area as of Wednesday morning and seven mutual aid fires, including one in the Municipal District of Peace.
Video shows suspects waving weapons, smashing glass in Toronto jewelry store robbery
Arrests have been made after five men were captured on video rampaging through a jewelry store in Toronto, waving weapons and smashing glass display cases.
Pilot proposes to flight attendant girlfriend in front of passengers
A Polish pilot proposed to his flight attendant girlfriend during a flight from Warsaw to Krakow, and she said yes.
Ottawa injects another $36M into fund for those seriously injured or killed by vaccines
The federal government has added $36.4 million to a program designed to support people who have been seriously injured or killed by vaccines since the end of 2020.
Ex-SNC executive sentenced to prison term in bridge bribery case
The RCMP says a former SNC-Lavalin executive has been sentenced to three and a half years in prison in connection with a bribery scheme for a bridge repair contract in Montreal.